Make the Xbox One Elite Controller paddles unique buttons
The controller, for me, is perfect in every way with one exception. The rear paddles aren't their own buttons and are only able to duplicate other buttons on the controller. I get that the main purpose is so you don't have to take your thumb off the right stick to press buttons, but what a missed opportunity.
I can't understand how they can add four new buttons but not give them their own identity. I know Xbox games aren't designed with these paddles in mind, but I'm using it for pc games. I don't need any face buttons duplicated. I need four more buttons all together. I'm sure there's some Xbox games that would benefit from this as well. It can't be too hard to add four additional mappings that don't necessarily have to be used.
I love the controller overall, but this is a huge oversight in my opinion. I can only hope they update the software someday. Please, Microsoft!
[Mod edit: This idea was merged with a similar post from Reynbow. Thanks, everyone!]
thats exactly my first though when i got my xbox elite controller,i hope they do this if not the paddles will be a wasted feature
I purchased this controller with the expectation that the four tab buttons (p1-p4) were additional bindable buttons that I could use for easier navigation on Xbox one's version of the game Elite: Dangerous. Upon opening and connecting it to my console, I was extremely displeased to find that the paddles serve no purposes other than to duplicate existing buttons on the controller, effectively making little more that a convenient button relocation. I am overwhelmingly dissatisfied, and I will be returning the controller tomorrow. This is absolutely ridiculous, and nowhere near reflects the $100 price increase from the base controller.
Also allow (limited) macros for the buttons - eg double tap B on single click :)
I really want this for elite dangerous (In all of its 4k xbox one x glory).
I agree completely. It would be nice in a game that multiple buttons are required to open different menu's (for instance in Elite Dangerous). Was actually the reason I forked over the 189.99 for this controller, only to get it home, play around until I couldn't figure out what I was doing wrong. Then googled it and stumbled across this particular post......darn....guess I should have read the fine print or done some research first (as I purchased it online). The idea stated in this post is spot on. For $100 more give us four new button options, just call it 25 bucks per button. Not 25 bucks per re-mapped button.
I also want to map one of the buttons for taking screenshots. If I map the X button to one of the paddles I can use the X button to do something different (like taking screenshots).
After spending that much on a controller I couldn't believe the only thing you can do with the four new paddles was to map them to existing buttons! Instead of mapping a paddle to 'jump' you have to map the paddle to X and then map X to 'jump'... that's silly and pointless.
I get that we'd need native support from the game to allow direct action mapping, but can't that just be part of the SDK and let developers support it or not? I spent all that money on a controller only to remove the paddles and I haven't used them since the day I bought it.
As for macros, this should be a no-brainer and completely within the control of the app. Allow 1 paddle trigger 2 or more button/bumper presses. I cannot believe this isn't possible.
the Game HHH7 commented
I play Shorters but often wenn i press firre buton i press the r-stick button buy mistake(Reflex) so is melee instead of shoting. ...
If you could map r-stick button to paddel 1 and then disable the orginal r-stick button ...that was geat for me no more melee for mistake...
Snd a option to programm to. Map a+x+L STICK UP. Would be great
LmG Xeir0 commented
If you want to really be able to map it out how you want or even add new buttons to it...
I was never here shhhh enjoy.
-- An alternative to Xbox Accessories App is "reWASD".
It even allows remapping of the 4 paddles to keyboard keys.
Got my elite yesterday thinking i would be able to use extra buttons not replacement of the orginal 4 buttons. Usless.
It appears the reason this feature is not available is the Xbox one controller support is likely a work over from the Xbox 360 controller for windows driver. (hence why they are both named Xinput in many games) To get true additional button support we would a driver with button mappings for P1-4 . Now with that settled Microsoft pc hardware designer gods please grant our wish, it can't be that difficult since you already have otherwise working source code.
REWASD WORKS LIKE A CHARM THANKS ALPHAPEACH4889!
Bought the Elite specifically for the 4 additional buttons(the paddles). Now it turns it doesn't have that! I feel so cheated. Please make an update to have those new 4 buttons available! It would be great if you could also map a button to a combination of buttons.
There is a free program called reWASD that looks just like the Xbox accessories app (Same interface and Community Builds) but lets you assign each button as both a unique keyboard button and/or controller buttons including the paddles.
I bought the elite controller for this reason and now regret it.
Siriously, we need two-button-macros. For say X+cross-up. This, two Buttons toghether, is essential needed all the time in Elite Dangerous.
Warrior Villain commented
This would be amazing setting programmable numbers, F keys, and etcetera on MMO games.
The Gatherer 13 commented
I think making the paddles macro-able is an absolute must and not to do so is a disappointing missed opportunity! I'm especially thinking about games like Ark: Survival Evolved where the lack of buttons on a controller makes some tasks pretty clunky.
Please do this!!!
Please do this.
If you guys are avoiding a possible unfair advantage then at least let them be macro-able. I'd suggest using a record function that includes real time delays from user input. i.e. that it records real time input and the macro plays that back exactly.