Give us feedback and ideas on games, game features and achievements.

A new MLB Game

There are no baseball games on X1 which is sad because I love the MLB. I want an MLB game on par with MLB The Show on Xbox One.

[Mod edit: This post was merged with a similar suggestion made by CamoflagxdMonky. Thanks, everyone!]

251 votes
Sign in
Signed in as (Sign out)

We’ll send you updates on this idea

ZeroSignal316ZeroSignal316 shared this idea  ·   ·  Flag idea as inappropriate…  ·  Admin →
HunterPunter312HunterPunter312 shared a merged idea: MLB 2k  ·   · 
lonegangster89lonegangster89 shared a merged idea: Make a mlb on xbox one  ·   · 
Froggy0057Froggy0057 shared a merged idea: MLB Game for Xbox One  ·   · 
Cpazel91Cpazel91 shared a merged idea: Bring back baseball to the xbox  ·   · 
Kenobi101Kenobi101 shared a merged idea: Return official MLB games to Xbox  ·   · 
CoolKid 1303CoolKid 1303 shared a merged idea: MLB  ·   · 
Japos47Japos47 shared a merged idea: Will there ever be a game like mlb the show for Xbox one?  ·   · 
CamoflagxdMonkyCamoflagxdMonky shared a merged idea: Xbox one needs a new MLB game!  ·   · 


Sign in
Signed in as (Sign out)
  • HunterPunter312HunterPunter312 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Hello, I have a concern about the series that has been discontinued. MLB 2k was a great series that a lot of gamers played and enjoyed. Many gamers are now joining Playstation because they wanted to play a baseball game. Many other gamers and I, believe that it is not fair that Xbox stopped supporting baseball, but have most other sports. Honestly, without baseball on Xbox, me and many others much like me, are about to leave Xbox to join Playstation because we cannot get our game. All that I am saying is, without an MLB game, Xbox gamers will get angry. Playing those old junky games is becoming horrible, the graffics are slowly decreasing, and we are all getting sick of it. They even had the nerves to take the MLB games off the store. This is horrible. We need to have our MLB 2k back. It is just giving Playstation profits over something that Microsoft could truly top. If the people of Xbox don't act quick, there will be a downfall in players. I mean yes, we have RBI Baseball, but it's junk. People do not want to play it, and it is making Xbox's rep look horrible for putting out one of the best games, and replacing it with crap. All that I, and many others, are asking for, is a new MLB 2k. It would be a great success, and I myself would play it. But if we don't, many people will retreat to playing with Playstation. So please hear me out and bring us a new game for us to love. Thank you

  • lonegangster89lonegangster89 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    As a fan of the Xbox consoles I think that there should be an MLB THE SHOW on xbox one. There has not been a baseball since 2k12, which was on xbox 360. As a user of the xbox one I would highly suggest that you guys come up with an MLB THE SHOW on xbox one

  • Froggy0057Froggy0057 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    MLB fans have been dying to play a baseball game in the Xbox One. The last one we got was MLB 2K12 for the Xbox 360 and ever since we've got no baseball. The Xbox One needs a good amazing baseball game whether it is made by EA Sports, 2K Sports, or Microsoft. It'll also attract more gamers to buy this console.

  • Cpazel91Cpazel91 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Bring back MLB to the Xbox consoles. It sucks having to buy a ps4 to purchase one game

  • Kenobi101Kenobi101 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Before 2K Baseball was shut down gamers had the opportunity to play baseball games on the Xbox 360. 2K wasn't great compared to MLB The Show but the option was there.

    Xbox One has been around for nearly 3 years now and all baseball fans have is the arcade styled RBI Baseball which no one actually wants. I and many others don't want to spend $400 on an Xbox One and the same price for a PS4 just to get MLB The Show and a small number of other exclusives which I don't play.

    Whether it is through EA Sports or Microsoft Studios or someone else you need to bring official baseball titles back to Xbox.

    It would also be beneficial if baseball fans, including myself, would vote and comment on the same post instead of making new ones.

  • Roy MulaRoy Mula commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    We have mostly every sports game now and not baseball no offense to rbi baseball but that is not really fun so we need a hole new game or a old one thats on the list for compatability program

  • RobSkillzzRobSkillzz commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    I can't stress enough about how badly a good baseball sim is needed on Xbox. I bought a Playstation only to play MLB The Show. If it weren't for that, the Xbox brand would take care of all my gaming needs. Please get us a baseball sim!!!

  • ccoykendallccoykendall commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate


  • critter171critter171 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    baseball baseball baseball there needs to be mlb baseball game for xbox one and xbox 360 but more xbox one... its a shame that baseball fans are screw over not being able to play the American past time. and I am youth umpire.

  • ReD8BaRRonReD8BaRRon commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    RBI is horrible. This is the only thing that makes me want a PS4. Which is why I'm prally gunna trade in my Xbox for $5 an get a system with a baseball game. Thanks MS

  • dellis22dellis22 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    For crying out loud!!! How's a company as big as Microsoft not going to have a baseball game? And rbi baseball don't count. MLB The Show on Playstation only, really? Do something about it. Have to say after 5 months of Xbox One, mostly underwhelmed.

  • soxbears2001soxbears2001 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    Seriously just buy a PS4 if you want baseball MS has already said they are not doing it. It's a gaping hole blah blah blah.. Sell X1 for PS4 you get all the same games almost and you get a MLB game on top of that.

  • DeeZumDeeZum commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    A baseball sim is a pretty key gap. Some will say that there is not a large enough market to justify the costs of developing and publishing a new MLB game; that there is not enough demand. There is a market out there,but Xbox users had become jaded from a underwhelming 2K-series which resulted in poor sales. My concern is that Microsoft isn't interested in this segment as they spent years sitting idly as 2K released mediocre products on their console as the only baseball representation. MS has righted a lot of the wrongs since XB1's launch. Let's hope a solid game for baseball fans is next on their list.

  • TheGotti98TheGotti98 commented  ·   ·  Flag as inappropriate

    12 years as an Xbox consumer and as soon as the Xbox 1 comes and I heard the announcement of no set date for a new MLB series I had to make the switch to PS4. Its a staple in my gaming! Bring back a solid MLB game and I will GLADLY sell back my PS4 to get the Xbox1.

← Previous 1

Feedback and Knowledge Base